Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

I’ve Consulted Over 50 Crypto Projects — Almost All of Them Do Not Know What They’re Doing

That friend of yours who made money with NFTs is not smarter than you.

You’ve read about all the accidental crypto millionaires. You feel demotivated that people are just excelling in life in a matter of days while it’s taking you years.

You finally decide to give it a shot. You speak to that friend and ask for advice.

Friend: “Alright, ARE YOU UP FOR THIS?!”

You: “Umm, Yes!”

Friend: “Close your eyes, and pick a random animal.”

You: “Okay… Monkey.”

Friend: “Nah, try something else.”

You: “Fine, a raccoon?”

Friend: “Love it, your project is going to be called RacooNFTokens”

You: “Alright… What do I do next?”

Friend: “We need a website, go buy one for a few hundred dollars from creativemarket or something. Then create a whitepaper. Oh, and you definitely need tokenomics for your community.”

You: “I do not know how to do any of that!”

Friend: “Do you live under a rock? Hire someone to do that for you. Fiverr is a very cheap option, go for it.”

*One week later*

You: “Alright, done! Should I now get an artist to draw the NFTs and sell them on a marketplace like Opensea?”

Friend: “Such an amateur. Of course not. We need to build your community. Create a Twitter, Discord, Reddit, and Telegram channels.”

You: “How am I supposed to get people to actually follow and join these channels?”

Friend: “Give me $5000 and don’t ask questions.”

*One week later*

You: “Dude, I have 100,000 followers on each! What did you do? Some sort of marketing?”

Friend: “Yeah, I did ‘some sort’ of marketing. Anyway, you are ready. Oh, and forget your old name and identity. Your new name is General Racoonious”

You: “That’s confusing, but I won’t ask why. Now should I create the NFTs?”

Friend: “You disappoint me every time. Of course not. Start building the hype of your presales. Convince them that this is going to be the next big NFTs. So that people would want to invest in your project, then we’ll create the NFTs in the end. Also, tell them we will build a play to earn game, people love that.”

You: “But after I release the NFTs, what guarantees that they would actually be good?”

Friend: “Absolutely nothing, but you would have made some money in the process. Tell them NFTs are risky, they should have known that. Then go buy yourself a car.”

Having worked with over 50 projects in the cryptocurrency, blockchain, DeFi, NFT, and play-to-earn gaming industries, I’ve noticed different motivations of people working in this industry.

Not referring to this in a sinister or fraudulent way, the above conversation was mainly sarcastic. However, it is true that all these markets nowadays are trending. Investors are psyched about them, and that’s why it is easier to get an investment in these industries at the moment.

Let’s take a trip to the past. Between 1995 till 2000, the world was crazy about startups operating on the internet. They’ve poured tens of billions of dollars into these “dot-com” startups. Eventually, this so called dot-com bubble burst and led to the failure of numerous internet startups, and billions were lost.

I am not saying we are in a similar bubble whatsoever. However, when there is hype for a specific industry, it usually escalates and then declines.

You should consider this before taking your friend’s advice on starting a new project in this space.

I’m Al, a business consultant in Zurich, Switzerland. I have been working in this entrepreneurship industry for over ten years.

This article could never compact all the information about these industries because that would be at least a 50-minute read.

What I will do is:

  • Share some stories of clients I worked with and their products in the space. (Any company names or products will be altered slightly to maintain confidentiality.)
  • Reflecting on those examples, I will write some dos and don’ts and provide a recommended white paper structure.

“Let’s create a game about Will Smith and add NFTs to it” — Client (Play 2 Earn)

I was approached to work on a market research document, a white paper, and a pitch deck for something similar to the above. The founder interested me because of three things:

  1. He was a hardcore gamer.
  2. He was a game developer as well.
  3. I could see an early version of the game he wanted to create (and it was quite good.)

He was trying to create a playable game in this industry compared to those just about NFTs and money. He aimed to create a game that people would want to play because of the actual game.

What I liked about this is that NFTs were an add-on. I was confident in his ability to create a game that people would like regardless of the NFT market’s performance. Adding NFTs and blockchain technology, while not necessary, is quite fitting for the gameplay itself and the marketplace.

Hence, we worked together, creating some good material in the process. He landed an equity seed investment of a few hundred thousand dollars to fulfill what he envisioned.

Takeaway: A game’s essence revolves around playing it. Create a game to be played, not to make a profit out of it.

“Let’s create a business out of the Metaverse, Crypto, and P2E Gaming Trends” — Client (Crypto Society)

If you create a business out of a trend, your business is itself a trend and will eventually decline.

A client approached me to create a crypto association of the elite. He believes that a society that is only dedicated to the wealthy crypto millionaires and the metaverse investors, for instance, would be fantastic to create and be an organizer of.

Their team was amazing by all means. They are very bright individuals and might see their vision come to reality. However, the main concern they are struggling with is the value provided.

They are doing it the other way around, starting with NFT, Crypto, and Metaverse, rather than the essential word — their value proposition.

As a project, the only concern is its scalability. Sure, build such an association, but remember, at the end of the day, you will always be a host for the elites following a trend.

Currently, they are attempting to raise funds for their project with a ticket size of more than $10 million since it’s going to be for the elite anyway.

Takeaway: A successful, scalable project should have an obvious problem and a robust solution, regardless of whether it is in the crypto industry.

“Let’s create an animal NFT collectible with an artist and sell it” — Client (Trending Animal)

A client came over with a project of creating an NFT collectible of a specific animal. I’ve noticed a surge of clients who ask for white papers for such projects.

What will happen in the future of this project or any similar ones?

I had a discussion with a financial analyst who worked at KPMG about this. He asked me, how should I project the pricing of such an NFT project?

I simply informed him that you can’t. You could, but it has a high probability of being inaccurate. The NFT market is quite novel and highly unstable. What makes people pay a specific amount of money for an NFT is an unanswerable question.

There are fantastic beautiful projects in this space that sell for millions. However, that does not mean that your raccoon will turn out to be an Ape. If you are lucky enough that a raccoon somehow becomes trending in a few days, your collection might kick off.

Takeaway: It worked with him, but that does not mean it will work with you.

“Let’s create an NFT project with complex tokenomics, and take the community’s advice, anonymously though” — Client (I-am-your-friend-NFT-project)

One of the most interesting clients I worked with wanted to give the community the feel of participation, which is fantastic.

The idea was simple. If the community participates in advising about the roadmap, tokenomics, and whitepaper, they would probably feel ownership enough to purchase the NFTs when the presale starts and boost the project.

However, he felt like they should be making almost all his decisions. Hence, they were modifying his white paper daily based on what each of them thought.

Imagine having over 300 members changing a project’s vision daily.

Takeaway: It’s good to involve the community, yet it is your project and vision at the end of the day.

“We don’t want to sound like we want to sell our NFTs, so let’s say we are all about the environment” — Client (SaveEarthNFT)

One of the significant challenges many people do not understand is that your end customer is not as naive as they might think.

A client approached with an incredible team as well an exciting project. They were focused on linking the environmental problems with NFTs and Crypto.

As a concept, it’s good. The problem lies in whether the environment is just pushed into the equation and is used rather than being the primary concern.

Takeaway: Have a clear objective of what you are doing. Your customers will read between the lines.

“Let’s create a new Airbnb-like platform based on crypto” — Client (Usable Blockchain Powered Product)

One of the most brilliant clients I’ve worked with approached me with a concept. The way we were talking led me to propose the use of blockchain in a specific aspect of his business. It was perfectly fitting.

Then he informed me that this is exactly what he is working on. I was sold.

This was one of the projects where you could actually feel the usability of blockchain that could provide value to everyone on the platform.

This company is now in the MVP creation phase.

Takeaway: A promising technology is a piece of your project’s puzzle, not to be thrown all over it.

I will tell you what I told them

1. Study the market. It's changing every week

This whole market is very volatile. I do not use my market research conducted a few months ago. I deem it useless.

An objective of a market research document is to validate and showcase a vision. When numbers jump rapidly every day due to something new, each research is a new one with a different conclusion.

2. Do not force the technologies on your work; sometimes, it's better not to have blockchain or crypto

You have to ask yourself and your tech team whether you need blockchain or you want it?

  Image by 101blockchains.com


Your project could be one of the most successful projects of the next ten years with absolutely no use of blockchain.

3. Successful entrepreneurs do not think about money from trends but actual value

If someone you know made money from such technology or a trend, take this as an inspiration to start your own thing. But do not have a narrow vision of only using these methods.

With or without NFT, blockchain, and crypto, the key to any business is providing value to someone. Do that, and it will all make sense.

My recommended Whitepaper Structure for you

While I use this with multiple projects, I usually tailor it based on the project. So what works for me and my projects might not work for you. So please take this as an initial phase, and enhance it as you move on.

  • Disclaimer — To avoid any legal misunderstandings, find a disclaimer online and modify it as per your project.
  • Introduction — You are telling a story. Introduce me, the reader, to it.
  • Executive Summary — You need to brief me on everything in this whitepaper. Show me some pie charts and visuals as well.
  • The Market — Showcase your market research and credible facts to know that you know your numbers.

Sometimes adding competitors could come in handy to observe how are you better than them, as well as an assurance point that this project already has a market.

  • The product —Now tell me what you’re doing, how you are doing it, which problems would be targetted, everything regarding your essence and value proposition.
  • Business and Revenue Model — How do you intend to monetize?
  • Tokenomics — You need to mention everything surrounding your plan of launching your token. This usually answers any question a person could have about your tokens and your use of funds.
  • Roadmap — Indicate what you have done and what you intend to do.
  • Team Members — Show me pictures and tell me more. Let me trust you.
  • Contact

Final Remark

What works for my clients and me does not necessarily have to work with you. There is no financial advice in this article. The idea is to inspire your thoughts on approaching a project correctly, what to do, and what not to do.

I’m Al, a business consultant in Zurich, Switzerland. I believe in the power of delivering value to you, the reader. Follow me on various social media platforms if you’re interested in the value of my content. Oh, and I also write content on my startup’s blog.

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • Thai regulator to crack down on deceptive cryptocurrency ads

    Cryptocurrency advertisements that contain false, exaggerated, distorted, concealed, or misleading information violate Thai regulations. Regulatory agencies in major cryptocurrency markets have also taken similar measures to minimize investment losses in cryptocurrencies. For example, the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) issued 450 illegal cryptocurrency advertising alerts in 2023 alone. In addition, in November 2023, the Spanish National Securities Market Commission, the main securities market regulatory agency, condemned fraudulent cryptocurrency asset promotion activities on X and reiterated the company's obligation to comply with local laws. The Thai Securities and Exchange Commission reminded cryptocurrency exchanges to include appropriate warnings about investment risks and to avoid attracting new users through special promotions. He warned that violating the above guidelines would result in "legal punishment".

  • Russia to impose cryptocurrency restrictions, exempting miners and central bank projects

    Russia will implement cryptocurrency restrictions, exempting miners and central bank projects. Starting from September 1st, Russia will impose strict restrictions on the circulation of cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin, only allowing the issuance of digital financial assets within its jurisdiction. Anatoly Aksakov, Chairman of the Financial Market Committee of the State Duma, led this initiative. This is part of a wider government effort to control the cryptocurrency ecosystem in the face of escalating geopolitical tensions. Aksakov stated that the upcoming legislation aims to restrict non-Russian cryptocurrency transactions to strengthen the dominance of the ruble. Meanwhile, recent reports indicate that Russian entities have used cryptocurrencies, particularly Tether's USDT, to purchase key components for military technology.

  • Ethereum stablecoin transaction volume exceeds $1 trillion so far in April, setting a new record

    On April 29th, The Block data shows that as of April 28th, the trading volume of stablecoins on the Ethereum blockchain reached a record high of $1.08 trillion in April, with DAI trading volume ranking first at $578.07 billion, followed by USDC at $268.15 billion in second place, and USDT at $198.62 billion in third place.

  • Shenyu: Up to one billion users' cloud input methods may have leaked input content. Please take immediate measures to reduce the risk.

    On April 29th, Cobo co-founder and CEO Shen Yu wrote on X platform that the cloud input method used by up to one billion users may have leaked input content. If you have entered mnemonic words or other sensitive information through any of the following cloud input methods, please take immediate measures to reduce the risk.

  • EU member states prepare to enforce landmark crypto law, MiCA

    The European Union is set to enforce MiCA, a crypto law that mandates national regulators to license and supervise service providers. While the regulation is EU-wide, countries can implement slightly different technical standards that crypto firms must adhere to. MiCA's specialized rules for stablecoin issuers will take effect in a few months, followed by licensing and other requirements for crypto firms broadly in December. Each jurisdiction must transpose the EU regulation into local law, select which of their regulators will oversee crypto, and prepare to authorize token issuers and other service providers. Regulators are facing challenges in implementing the new legislation, particularly in terms of licensing requirements, and each country's crypto industry has its own concerns about implementation and proposed laws.

  • The total open interest of BTC contracts on the entire network dropped to $29.83 billion

    According to Coinglass data, the total open position of BTC futures contracts on the entire network is 478,180 BTC, equivalent to 29.83 billion US dollars.

  • An independent Bitcoin miner obtained the entire 3.125 BTC block reward by verifying block 841,286

    On April 29th, independent mining pool ckpool's software engineer and administrator Con Kolivas posted on social media that a miner had mined the 282nd independent block in Bitcoin history. The miner's computing power at the time was about 120PH, which is equivalent to about 0.12 EH, with an average of about 12 PH per week, accounting for about 0.02% of the total network hash rate.

  • South Korea to formally establish an investigation unit focused on digital asset crimes

    The South Korean Ministry of Justice and the Ministry of Interior and Safety will begin discussions in early May to elevate the Joint Investigation Team for Virtual Asset Crimes to an official department. The purpose of this promotion is to solidify the department's position, as it currently operates as a temporary organization under the Seoul Southern District Prosecutor's Office and may be dissolved. The change is expected to improve efficiency through the appointment of new prosecutors and budget allocation, according to Sae-ki. The department is composed of about 30 experts from seven financial and tax regulatory agencies and was established in July 2023 as South Korea's first investigative agency focused on digital asset crimes.

  • Hong Kong virtual asset spot ETF debuts today

    Today, six virtual asset spot ETFs were launched online in Hong Kong. The six virtual asset spot ETFs issued this time are from Huaxia (Hong Kong), Boshi International, and Jiashi International. The three institutions have certain differences in product fees, trading, issuance, and virtual asset platforms.

  • The total open interest of Bitcoin contracts on the entire network reached US$30.62 billion

    According to Coinglass data, the total open position of Bitcoin futures contracts on the entire network is 480,870 BTC (approximately $30.62 billion).