Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

Viewing Bitcoin’s Price in the Lens of Macro Liquidity Modelling

Validated Venture

Abstract

2022 was a tough year for Bitcoin and Crypto Markets. We have seen cascades of capitulations. While people are expecting a $10k Bitcoin price, the market seems to have proved them wrong. We review the price development of Bitcoin in this cycle and arrive at a more solid expectation.

Bitcoin, being a risky asset, together with other major cryptos, are significantly affected by the contraction and expansion of macro liquidity. This analysis views Bitcoin in the lens of macro liquidity modelling and debunks the major driving forces behind Bitcoin and cryptos.

This analysis is composed of three sections. The first section defines and explains the correlation between the liquidity source (Fed Balance Sheet in this case) with the general crypto market as a risky asset. The second section debunks major driving forces behind the Fed Balance Sheet Liquidity. The third (last) section suggests various important Bitcoin on-chain metrics which can be interpreted together with the liquidity models.

Chapter 1 — Defining the correlation between liquidity source (Fed Balance Sheet) and Risky Assets (Cryptos)

1.1 A surfeit of liquidity in the Fed Balance Sheet pumped risky assets

Since 2020 started the Covid Crash, the Fed adopted QE and inflated their balance sheet significantly. The money created circulated into various markets, and crypto was one of the outperforming risky assets.

Below is a chart featuring the correlation between Fed Balance Sheet and risky assets. The green shaded area represents the liquidity bootstrap period when the Fed injected tremendous liquidity.

1.2 Sub-zero rates encouraged more economic activities (lending & borrowing, investments)

There was also an additional contributor to Crypto’s crazy rally in 2020 — U.S. T-bill yields hanging sub-zero levels, plus a surfeit of liquidity in commercial banks.

The light-blue shaded area represents the sub-zero rates period, which incentivized economic activities. It is also worth noticing that the excess liquidity in commercial banks came from the Fed, aggressively purchasing treasuries from these banks. As the interest rate does not guarantee considerable returns that the yield is at a sub-zero level, money instead seeks for more lucrative opportunities other than the money market, such as equities. Borrowing and lending activities were readily enabled so that institutional adoption was fast-paced in 2020.

1.3 Quantitative Tightening Stealthily Began Before the Fed Announced

The situation was tricky because liquidity started to dry up in Jan 2022, signatured by the exponentially increasing amount of Reverse Repo (Please refer to section 2.1 for a complete explanation of Reverse Repo).

The red shaded area represents the period where the demand for Reverse Repo surged exponentially, money preferred less risky investments instead of risky assets.

The expression of “Quantitative Tightening stealthily began in Jan 2022” depicts the nadir of TGA in Dec 2021. The increase in TGA in Jan 2022 is, in other words, a decrease in bank reserves, which was detrimental to economic activities, especially market participation in risky assets. Driving forces behind the liquidity will be elaborated in Chapter 2.

Chapter 2 — Debunking Fed Balance Sheet and extracting liquidity drivers

The Fed Balance Sheet is mainly composed of three important elements when considering effective drivers of liquidity: Total Assets, Treasury General Account, and Reverse Repurchase Agreement. It is critical to understand how these three elements affect the markets.

2.1 Understanding Reverse Repurchase Agreement

Reverse Repurchase Agreement is an instrument used by the Fed to control the Fed Funds Rate and liquidity to “cool the markets”[1].

The Fed adjusts the Effective Federal Funds Rate (i.e., interest rate) by raising and lowering the award rate for Reverse Repo and Interest Rate On Reserve Balance (IORB).

In simple terms, when the Fed raises interest rate, they increase the award rate for Reverse Repo, making Reverse Repo more attractive because the rewarding interest rate increases, therefore money market funds will park their huge liquidity into RRP. Thus, liquidity is absorbed by the Fed, since it is the best risk-free investment to all investors.

[1] For a complete explanation, please refer to my report: https://mediums.com/huobi-research/reverse-repurchase-agreements-as-an-indicator-for-btc-ca861944289

Please note that RRP started to climb up significantly since April 2021, despite that the Fed kept inflating their Balance Sheet. QT actually began in mid-April 2021, indicated by the purple line, when Total Asset of Fed (minus RRP) peaked. Since April, Reverse Repo was increasing significantly, withdrawing liquidity from the markets.

Fig 5 shows that the Balance Sheet Minus Reverse Repo peaked and coincidently Bitcoin also peaked at that time. Bitcoin entered a distribution phase (could be due to less liquidity availability, refer to Net Liquidity first time tumbling and struggling to climb up higher), plus denoted by its Wyckoff Distribution pattern.

There is no doubt that RRP exhibits an inverse relationship with risky assets, therefore I created an Inverted RRP Indicator, illustrating the positive correlation with risky assets.

Please be reminded that a flattened RRP means an ease (less hawkish) on the liquidity availability, the market could react in a positive way, causing potential bear market rallies.

Conclusion: A surge in Inverted RRP leads to a greater chance of risky assets rallying. At the moment, Inverted RRP remains structurally flat, and equities should be reverting to the mean level in this period.

2.2 Understanding Treasury General Account

The Treasury General Account is the checking account opened by the Department of the U.S. Treasury in the Federal Reserve Bank, from which the U.S. government makes all of its payments. The Treasury General Account is used for U.S. government disbursements, where tax payments are deposited, and where funds from the sale of Treasury debt is collected.

The TGA sits on the Fed’s balance sheet as a liability, along with notes, coins and bank reserves. But the Fed’s liabilities must match its assets. So a drop in the TGA must see a rise in bank reserves and vice versa. Last year’s reserves drain (2021) was masked by the Fed’s $3 trillion in asset purchases. But when cash flows leave the TGA, bank reserves rise — potentially increasing lending or investment in the wider economy or markets.

According to Fig 7, the green shaded area was the period where the Fed spent down the TGA from 1.6 Trillion to almost zero, offsetting the effect by the surging RRP and inflating the Net Liquidity, thus, causing Nasdaq to rally.

2.3 Interpreting the Fed Balance Sheet, TGA and RRP together with bills and coupons issuance to forecast liquidity availability

This Net Liquidity Model was effectively functioned in 2020–2022 until recently the Fed hit its debt ceiling.

Having its total debt hitting the $31,381 billion debt ceiling indicates that the Treasury cannot issue more bills and coupons unless the balance of TGA is exhausted; when all the funds in TGA are budgeted and incurring as cost to fund government spending, official proposals must be submitted in the congress to raise its debt ceiling. Less bills will be issued when TGA is specifically spent on government expenditures as less bills will be needed. However, coupons, longer duration bonds are not affected. The demand for T- Bills (a probable cause could be the desire to meet ROI requirement of end investors)has to be settled somewhere else. It is unlikely the demand will go to crypto and risky assets under this bearish economic environment, which leaves the only haven being RRP. Therefore, in the coming months, RRP (including Foreign RRPs) will play more significant role rather than the TGA account in the Fed Liquidity Model.

Therefore, it is also crucial to monitor 2023 Q1 bills and coupon issuance[2]. If the Treasury issues less bills, the demand for these bills will be shifted to RRP. If the Treasury issues more bills, RRP will drop and risky assets might have a chance to rally. (Also important to monitor RRP levels).

[2] Data can be found at: https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/221/Tentative-Auction-Schedule.pdf

2.4 Liquidity Model Reference

The Real Net Liquidity takes into account the TGA, RRP as well as new debts issued by the Treasury to track the trends of risky assets.

2.5 Fed Funds Rate Projection

This is a projection of the upcoming FOMC rate hikes probabilities. The general trend is inclined to predict rate cuts in 2024, which indicates that interest rate will maintain at the terminal rate of 5.25% throughout 2023.

In my opinion, under high interest rate regime, investment sentiment will be dire; risky assets are unlikely to rally as money now prefers less risky investments. Under such macro condition, it is almost impossible to witness another boom of that in 2020.

Nonetheless, it is not necessarily implying the doomsday of crypto, as the market is always forward-looking, let alone the market has effectively responded to the rate hikes of the Fed as it should have. The following Bitcoin Price Models suggest that the crypto market has come to a historical “Value Zone” where smart money would accumulate. Without further bad news coming out in the near future, crypto is within the bottom range right now.

Chapter 3 — Bitcoin Price Models

3.1 Bitcoin Holders Cost Basis Model

This multi-cost basis model suggests it has entered the capitulation period once in a 4-year cycle. According to CVDD, somewhere between 13.5k-16k could be the final capitulation floor price. The grey shaded area is where Long Term Holder Cost Basis is higher than Short Term Holder Cost Basis. This only occurs once in a 4-year cycle, which depicts a typical capitulation period.

3.2. Realised Profit and Loss

A diminishing realized loss was incurred in recent capitulation; a further capitulation event accompanied with a minimized realised loss implies the absence of sellers, and it is typically spotted in a bull market that very few is willing to sell.

3.3 Stablecoin Supply Ratio Model

The Stablecoin Supply Ratio (SSR) has been effective for confirming a market bottom when the SSR penetrates the lower boundary of its lower band standard deviation. Currently it is residing near its lower boundary, which could possibly indicate that the purchasing power in stablecoin has nearly reached a threshold for an uptrend to follow.

3.4 Bitcoin vs Yields

Yields are still in an uptrend. DXY has been showing signs of weakness. Yields have developed an inverse correlation to risky assets, and a bull market can be detected when yields are on a downward slope. Strong yields also discourage DeFi growth and development; not until the yields are lower than current offering of DeFi can the TVL of DeFi to recover.

3.5 Bitcoin Cycles Comparison

Finally, through the lens of Bitcoin in a 4 Year Cycle, we are now at the historical “Value Zone”. This zone begins on the 700th day of previous cycles which usually lasts for 2–3 weeks. In this zone, capitulation event strikes and it comes with FUD. The Crypto Fear and Greed Index now is 27 (out of 100). If Bitcoin cycles are to be scanned since its every Halving, the zone typically begins since the 850th Day and lasts for 3 months.

Chapter 4 — Conclusion

4.1 Bitcoin has entered the historical value zone after cascades of capitulations.

All of the Bitcoin Metrics mentioned above are hinting that the price of Bitcoin is currently undervalued. It is possible that we see Bitcoin price reverts to its fair value before the FTX implosion. However, further rally to reclaim $30,000 or above has to be justified by a positive macro liquidity condition plus improved investment sentiment towards risky assets.

4.2 While RRP remains flat, risky assets should be seeing less downward pressure.

It is crucial to monitor the Real Net Liquidity Indicator and the Inverted RRP for a trend continuation confirmation. In the other words, these two indicators needs to show signs of strength continually for Crypto markets to continue the rallies.

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • Indonesia's Financial Services Authority to Regulate Crypto Industry in 2025 with Evaluation in Regulatory Sandbox

    Indonesia's Financial Services Authority (OJK) will take over regulation of the crypto industry from the commodities agency Bappebti. Crypto firms must undergo evaluation in a regulatory sandbox before being licensed to operate in the country. The OJK aims to prioritize consumer protection and education, and firms operating without evaluation in the sandbox will be considered illegal. The sandbox provides a safe and isolated environment for testing and innovation development, helping to enhance security and responsible management in the financial sector. Once under OJK's oversight, crypto assets will likely be reclassified as financial instruments.

  • The Shenzhen Illegal Fund Raising Prevention Office issued a risk warning on the "DDO digital options" business

    The Shenzhen Office for Preventing and Dealing with Illegal Fundraising issued a risk warning regarding the "DDO digital option" business. The activities related to the DDO digital option business conducted in the name of Dingyifeng International are essentially the issuance and trading of virtual currencies. According to the "Notice on Further Preventing and Dealing with Risks of Speculation in Virtual Currency Trading" jointly issued by ten departments including the People's Bank of China in September 2021, it is clear that virtual currency-related business activities are illegal financial activities, and overseas virtual currency exchanges providing services to residents within China are also illegal financial activities. The activities conducted by Dingyifeng International in the name of serving residents within China are suspected of illegal fundraising and other illegal financial activities. Our office has organized relevant departments to carry out work, resolutely deal with illegal fundraising and criminal activities, and seriously investigate the legal responsibilities of relevant personnel. (Shenzhen Local Financial Supervision and Administration Bureau)

  • The Hong Kong Legislative Council plans to review the relevant stable currency consultation and sandbox legislation at the end of this year or next year

    Hong Kong legislator Wu Jiezhuang revealed that Hong Kong will release stablecoin consultation and sandbox (computer security mechanism), which will allow the industry to innovate digital asset projects in the sandbox environment. Relevant legislation will be reviewed in the Legislative Council at the end of this year or next year, which will help the entire digital asset industry ecosystem. Hong Kong has been improving the digital asset (virtual asset) market on different legal levels. Last year, there were regulations on virtual currency trading platforms and issuance systems.

  • Vitalik: Humanity needs to create a world where blockchain and artificial intelligence work together

    Vitalik Buterin, the founder of Ethereum, stated at BiddleAsia 2024 held at Signiel Seoul in the Songpa district on March 28 that artificial intelligence is a huge market and its importance is increasing day by day. We need to create a world where blockchain and artificial intelligence work together. Artificial intelligence can now create applications with 100 to 500 lines of code. Vitalik also stated that the ability to write 10,000 lines of code can eliminate most of the bugs in the Ethereum virtual machine.

  • South Korean RWA blockchain technology development company PARAMETA completed a new round of financing of approximately US$7.5 million

    South Korean RWA blockchain technology development company PARAMETA announced the completion of a new round of financing of KRW 9 billion (approximately $7.5 million), with Shinhan Hyperconnect Investment Fund under Shinhan Venture Investment and Korea Asset Investment & Securities participating. As of now, the company's total financing has reached KRW 25 billion (approximately $20.8 million). PARAMETA plans to use this investment to expand its own blockchain technology research and development capabilities to meet RWA technology needs and expand from core technologies such as engines/chains to service applications. Relevant services are expected to be launched within the year.

  • Incheon, South Korea launches blockchain hub city

    South Korea announced on the 28th that it will establish a blockchain technology innovation support center in the Songdo Michu Building in the second half of this year. Incheon was finally selected as a participant in the "2024 Regional Blockchain Technology Innovation Support Center Construction Project" jointly organized by the Korean Ministry of Science, ICT and Future Planning and the Korea Internet & Security Agency (KISA). Incheon is the third region to be selected after Busan and Daegu. In February last year, Incheon established a dedicated blockchain department and formulated a four-year plan to create a blockchain center city, which was promised by Incheon Mayor Liu Zhengfu. After being selected, Incheon will receive KRW 1.8 billion in government funding.

  • BTC breaks through $70,000

    The market shows that BTC has broken through $70,000 and is now reporting at $70,003.6. The intraday decline has reached 0.58%, and the market fluctuation is large. Please be prepared for risk control.

  • Base TVL exceeded US$3 billion, with an increase of 71.79% in the past 7 days

    According to the latest data from L2beat, supported by cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase, the total locked value (TVL) on the Base chain, a layer 2 solution for Ethereum, has surpassed $3 billion. At the time of writing, it has dropped to $2.99 billion, with a 7-day increase of 71.79%, reaching a new historical high.

  • Ethereum liquidity re-pledge agreement TVL exceeds US$7.4 billion, continuing to hit new highs

    According to DeFiLlama data, the total value locked (TVL) in Ethereum's liquidity re-staking protocol has reached a new high of $7.406 billion. The top five protocols ranked by TVL are:

  • Cointime March 24th News Express

    1.Moonbeam has completed the airdrop distribution of Polkadot ecological meme currency PINK2.The total number of Ordinals inscriptions minted exceeded 63 million, and the fee income exceeded 400 million US dollars.3.BOME founder: 2543 SOL will be transferred to the new address and sent to 415 wallets as a reward refund4.BottoDAO, a decentralized autonomous organization focusing on digital art NFTs, completed US$1.67 million in financing, led by 1kx5.The current open interest on Binance BTC contracts is approximately $7.13 billion6. Polyhedra Network: We are working on introducing zero-knowledge proof technology to Bitcoin to realize smart contract functions and high-speed cross-chain bridging.8.Stable currency project DYAD has been launched on the KEROSENEN airdrop query website 7.After the Ethereum Dencun upgrade, the L2 rollup gas cost for publishing Chainlink oracle reports dropped by 99% 9.Partisia token MPC was launched on multiple exchanges such as Kucoin, and an airdrop of 25 million tokens was launched to encourage ecological participation. 10.L2 Tech to Fuel Bitcoin (BTC) Price Rise