Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

Programmed Royalties and Creative Experiments in NFTs

The NFT space sometimes feels overloaded with copycat projects, and there can be prolonged periods when an overriding theme or aesthetic takes hold. At these moments, multiple new launches will be configured similarly, and originality takes a back seat.

At the same time, though, crypto and NFTs move quickly, and so, despite the constant presence of mimicry and trend-chasing, innovations can unfold seemingly overnight, and the urge to experiment is ever-present. This is all in the nature of an ecosystem where regulation and traditional corporate boundaries have been, up to now at least, more or less non-existent.

With all that in mind, it should be no surprise that NFTs are changing rapidly, and there are some new approaches that are currently grabbing attention.

The Royalties Debate

One of the initial often touted benefits of creating and selling art (and other content) via NFTs was that creators could take a fixed royalties payment every time one of their NFTs was sold. This was on top of being able to profit directly from initial sales, meaning creators could have a strong relationship with buyers, exercise close control over what they released, and then, through royalties, receive ongoing income from secondary sales.

This model attracted artists to work with NFTs, and while profiting from one’s art is still a tough process, it at least provided one more approach to experiment with, while creating an interesting, sometimes artistically inspiring crossover between the worlds of art, crypto and finance. However, a flaw in the model is that royalties are not hard-coded into NFTs. That is, royalties are enforced by NFT marketplaces in a traditional web setup that, in this particular respect, doesn’t make full use of blockchain technology.

While everyone was talking about web3, this arrangement was decidedly web2, and competitor marketplaces have since come along that, to the benefit of traders, but not artists, allow NFTs to be bought and sold without royalties. This bypassing of royalties by newer platforms has generated often heated debate, as artists, not for the first time, felt that they were getting a rough deal: creating the content on which NFT markets thrive, but having a valuable income stream abruptly severed.

Most observers are sympathetic to creators, but at the same time, the culture around crypto and NFTs are tech-oriented, meaning what can be done (such as royalty-free marketplaces), will be tried, and the dominant ethos is that problems should be solved mechanically and on-chain.

Limit Break

A well-known web3 gaming company called Limit Break is now furthering the debate with its own solution to problems around NFT royalties. Limit Break was founded by Gabriel Leydon, a prominent and influential voice in both gaming and NFTs, and the company’s DigiDaigaku NFT collection is highly valued.

The forward-thinking gaming company has already stirred the pot by pushing a new approach to web3 gaming branded as free-to-own (meaning, as the name suggests, that in-game NFT assets are initially distributed for free), and has now posted its plans for on-chain, programmable royalties.

The system they propose is opt-in and involves staking one’s NFT for a wrapped token which has royalties programmed in. Furthermore, those royalties can take a variety of formats, thereby opening the door, for example, to royalty sharing and all the commercial applications that might permit.

However, the system doesn’t begin and end with royalties, as many other variables could be incorporated, on-chain, into a wrapped NFT. Some of Limit Break’s suggestions include setting price parameters on secondary sales, enabling rewards such as airdrop eligibility, and including in-game utilities.

Above all, the emphasis is on flexibility and moving NFTs beyond their current stage of development. If NFT use, up to now, has been static, as a vehicle for art and design, then Limit Break is pushing for a more dynamic approach, which should allow NFTs to be integrated more usefully in gaming and other fields.

Layer 2 Collections

While Layer 2 is a technical term referring to protocols that operate on top of a main blockchain (such as Arbitrum on top of Ethereum), in a much looser sense of the term, we’re now seeing an experiment with a second layer NFT collection, meaning a project that is created on top of an already existing collection.

The new project in question is called Mutant Hounds, and it’s been performing well, but the aspect of note is that it’s built around existing content from the Yuga Labs company, in particular, the Mutant Ape Yacht Club collection.

Mutant Hounds is slick and well-executed. When it comes to continuity, the artwork and world-building splice together seamlessly with the Yuga Labs NFTs it draws on, and Mutant Hounds has now established value of its own, while (temporarily, at least) adding value to and drawing attention towards Yuga’s pre-existing Mutant Apes collection.

Where Mutant Hounds is headed long-term, remains to be seen, but it has demonstrated that in a field as inherently permissive as NFTs, existing assets can suddenly be taken in unexpected creative directions by new parties.

Taking these two developments together, enhanced NFT programmability, and the creation of projects on top of projects, we see, in NFTs, a fertile area of development, in which flexibility and creative experimentation are always at the forefront.

While the results might seem a little chaotic, and the landscape can, at times, be disorienting to navigate, we should expect, in the long term, a wealth of new concepts and novel applications.

NFT
Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • Stablecoin protocol Ethena on BNBChain has been hacked

    The stablecoin protocol Ethena on BNBChain has been hacked, causing a loss of 480 BNB, worth about $290,000, as monitored by PeckShieldAlert.

  • Singapore-based Bitcoin Layer2 Project BEVM Raises Tens of Millions in Seed and Series A Funding

    Singapore-based Bitcoin Layer2 project, BEVM, has completed its seed round and part of its Series A round, raising tens of millions of USD from over 20 investors including RockTree Capital, Waterdrip Capital, and ViaBTC Capital. The project's Series A valuation has reached $200m and aims to accelerate its international development and roll-out. BEVM is an EVM-compatible Bitcoin Layer2 network built on Taproot Consensus, which uses $BTC as gas and aims to bring 10% of $BTC into its Layer2 network environment. The project's mainnet is scheduled to launch on March 28th and has already implemented decentralized Bitcoin cross-chain custody services through Schnorr Signature, MAST, and Bitcoin SPVs.

  • Ethereum on-chain DEX transaction volume exceeded $2.1 billion yesterday

    According to DeFiLlama data, the trading volume of DEX on the Ethereum blockchain on March 28th was 2.111 billion US dollars, ranking first. The daily trading volume of DEX on the BSC chain was 1.398 billion US dollars, ranking second; the daily trading volume of DEX on the Solana chain was 1.097 billion US dollars, ranking third.

  • Taiwan’s Ministry of Interior has approved the establishment of a cryptocurrency industry association

    Taiwan's Ministry of the Interior has approved the application of the local cryptocurrency industry to establish an industry association. The local cryptocurrency industry working group, which was established last year to prepare for the establishment of the industry association, said that the working group now needs to complete all preparations and officially establish the cryptocurrency industry association by the end of June as required by the government. The working group is currently composed of 22 cryptocurrency companies, including Taiwan's major exchanges such as MaiCoin and BitoPro. The working group pointed out that ACE Exchange has been expelled from the group because the troubled exchange is under investigation by prosecutors for improper behavior by its former executives.

  • Grayscale ETH Trust negative premium rate is 22.77%

    According to ChainCatcher news and Coinglass data, the Grayscale Bitcoin Trust Fund (GBTC) has a premium rate of 0.02%. The Grayscale ETH Trust has a negative premium rate of 22.77%, and the ETC Trust has a negative premium rate of 36.58%.In addition, the Grayscale BCH Trust has a premium rate of 238.13%, the LTC Trust has a premium rate of 380.60%, the SOL Trust has a premium rate of 515.93%, the MANA Trust has a premium rate of 726.65%, the LINK Trust has a premium rate of 713.66%, and the FIL Trust has a premium rate of 3057.89%.

  • Net inflows into spot Bitcoin ETFs reached $179 million on March 28

    Spot on Chain, a blockchain data monitoring platform, posted on social media that the net inflow of spot bitcoin ETF on March 28th reached 179 million US dollars, a decrease of 26.9% compared to the previous trading day. After 54 trading days, the total net inflow accumulated to 12.13 billion US dollars, which is the level before the last fully negative trading week. BlackRock's iShares Bitcoin ETF (IBIT) and Grayscale's GBTC both saw a significant slowdown in daily inflows and outflows on March 28th.

  • Bitcoin spot ETF had a total net inflow of US$179 million yesterday, and the ETF net asset ratio reached 4.25%

    According to SoSoValue data, the Bitcoin spot ETF had a total net inflow of $179 million yesterday (March 28th, US Eastern Time).Yesterday, Grayscale's ETF GBTC had a net outflow of $104 million, and its historical net outflow is $14.77 billion. The Bitcoin spot ETF with the highest net inflow yesterday was BlackRock's ETF IBIT, with a net inflow of approximately $95.12 million, and its historical total net inflow has reached $13.96 billion. The second is Fidelity's ETF FBTC, with a net inflow of approximately $68.09 million yesterday, and its historical total net inflow has reached $7.56 billion.As of now, the total net asset value of Bitcoin spot ETF is $59.1 billion, and the ETF net asset ratio (market value compared to the total market value of Bitcoin) is 4.25%, with a historical total net inflow of $12.12 billion.

  • ON–216: NFTs

    Coverage on NodeMonkes, Pudgy Penguins, CryptoPunks, Mad Lads, and NFTs in Safes.

  • Cointime March 24th News Express

    1.Moonbeam has completed the airdrop distribution of Polkadot ecological meme currency PINK2.The total number of Ordinals inscriptions minted exceeded 63 million, and the fee income exceeded 400 million US dollars.3.BOME founder: 2543 SOL will be transferred to the new address and sent to 415 wallets as a reward refund4.BottoDAO, a decentralized autonomous organization focusing on digital art NFTs, completed US$1.67 million in financing, led by 1kx5.The current open interest on Binance BTC contracts is approximately $7.13 billion6. Polyhedra Network: We are working on introducing zero-knowledge proof technology to Bitcoin to realize smart contract functions and high-speed cross-chain bridging.8.Stable currency project DYAD has been launched on the KEROSENEN airdrop query website 7.After the Ethereum Dencun upgrade, the L2 rollup gas cost for publishing Chainlink oracle reports dropped by 99% 9.Partisia token MPC was launched on multiple exchanges such as Kucoin, and an airdrop of 25 million tokens was launched to encourage ecological participation. 10.L2 Tech to Fuel Bitcoin (BTC) Price Rise

  • Cointime March 17th News Express

    1.Derivatives trading platform D2X completed US$10 million in Series A financing, led by Point72 Ventures2.6 wallets received ARB from the vesting contract and deposited 8.95 million ARB to Binance3.BOME TOP1 holders will sell 190 million BOME for the first time, making a profit of US$3.76 million4.Manta Network joins hands with ether.fi to launch the first phase of Restaking Paradigm, staking ETH to earn double EtherFi airdrop points5.A giant whale took out 1,000 MKR from Aave and sold them in batches, worth $2.88 million6.Bitcoin fee income was only about $20.3 million this week, a drop of more than 33%7.BOME Token Price Surge Reflects Cryptocurrency Market Dynamics8.ETHVietnam anonymous MACI voting is officially launched. This is the first time aMACI voting technology has been used in a large-scale encryption event.9.Bitcoin Whales Withdraw Massive BTC Reserve From Exchanges, Impacting Bitcoin Price Surge10.USDC circulation increased by 1.3 billion in the past 7 days